One big influencer vs. hundreds of small creators


Hey,

RIP to big influencers. Trust now belongs to micro-affiliates.

Why brands half your size are getting your best creators and scaling quicker than you on TikTok Shop

Here's a pattern I see all the time.

A big brand comes to TikTok Shop. They pay a few big influencers or spend a ton on ad spend, but sales are pretty quiet.

Here's the solution.

The influencer era is over. The creator group is next.

While influencers sell attention, a good TikTok Shop affiliate is selling trust, because on TikTok Shop, buyers don't search, but they're actually scrolling, looking for good videos to watch. They only will buy when somebody they trust actually will show them and pitch them the product effectively.

Famous faces reading scripts or giving testimonials about products do not solve this problem, because buyers can actually tell the difference. Real TikTok Shop affiliates that actually know what they're doing will use your product and be a good fit to recommend that product. That's why the brands that are growing fastest on the platform are the ones that are chasing building the best creator group possible.

1. Count orders, not views.​
A big influencer may have a big crowd, but it's going to be their crowd and not yours. While you can get lots of views with this strategy, most brands end up getting few actual buyers from it.

2. Brief creators on doubts, not hype.​
Creators saying how awesome a product is will not get sales. In most cases, what actually sells is answering the doubts that buyers have on camera. Take your top five customer questions or comments and use those to create effective videos.

3. Give creators something to believe in.​
Creators will not rally behind the biggest product. They'll rally behind a brand that builds community with them and gives them a way to win and earn long term. Build a creator community that genuinely feels more like a movement than a one-off campaign.

Want your TikTok Shop math done for you?

Book a free discovery call with my team. We'll look at your hero products, your margins, and what an affiliate army would cost you, all in.

You'll get a straight answer on whether TikTok Shop fits your brand right now.

​Book your free discovery call →​

A creator group has three jobs

Most brands only recruit, and then they give up when TikTok Shop doesn't work for them fast enough.

Job 1: Recruit. Get the right creators in the door.

Job 2: Activate. Turn joiners into posters. Most creators who join never post. This is where programs stall.

Job 3: Keep. Turn posters into a community. Look at who is still posting after 30, 60 and 90 days.

Each job only works on the people that the job before it brought in. As a quick check, look at your influencer roster from the last 90 days. Sort creators into categories such as joined, posted once, and still posting. If most are stuck at joined, you do not yet have an affiliate program. You just have a recruiting list.

A list is not a community. A real creator community is a place where creators talk to you and each other and keep coming back consistently. Here's what that looks like: a proper Discord group with a wins channel, clear pay, weekly winners, and scripts being shared, and fast answers where people do not feel ignored. When creators see other creators getting paid, they post more, and when they post more, everyone learns and wins faster.

When this is the wrong move

This isn't for every brand. Skip it if:
- Your margins can't pay creators a real cut
- You can't ship fast
- You need big results in 30 days

Communities take time to build. The first 90 days feel slow. That's where most brands quit.

Why this matters for big brands

Big brands already have the product, the reviews, and the budget.

What they usually don't have is a group of creators who talk about the product every day.

That's the gap.

For context, our team has driven 1B+ views and built a network of 39,000+ creators. We manage well over $1 million in GMV on TikTok Shop right now .

We also helped Pudgy Penguins sell out across Walmart USA in five days.

And in one case study, a brand we launched on TikTok Shop hit $543K in GMV in just over 3 months on the platform .

Want help with TikTok Shop scaling?

Book a free discovery call with my team. We'll look at your hero products, your margins, and what an affiliate army would cost you, all in.

You'll get a straight answer on whether TikTok Shop fits your brand right now.

​Book your free discovery call →​

Talk soon,

Noah

Noah Frydberg
CEO & Founder, Maverick Creative
​

P.S.-- Hit reply and tell me the one TikTok Shop question your team keeps asking. It might be a future issue.

Disclosure: Most brands that sell on TikTok Shop, including established 8-figure brands, find that reaching $200,000 a month in GMV, is extremely difficult and uncommon. Results shared here are examples of what has worked for some past Maverick Creative clients, not typical results, income claims, or guarantees, and your results will vary. This content is for education only, not financial, legal, or tax advice.

Noah Frydberg, CEO @ Maverick Creative

Subscribe for valuable content about how to scale your brand, from an award-winning Tiktok Shop Partner agency.

Read more from Noah Frydberg, CEO @ Maverick Creative

Hey, I've been speaking with a lot of brands that are currently in the middle of a big retail push. They're trying to get these retailers on their side, and they often wonder if TikTok Shop should wait or if TikTok Shop should be a priority in order to help their growth in retail. Here's my answer after actually helping brands scale in retail, including one launch that led to a brand selling out in Walmart USA in 5 days. Stick around to the end of this newsletter for a free giveaway. Why...

Hey, I've met quite a few brand owners that have become seven- or eight-figure brands solely off of Meta ads or Amazon. Yet when it comes to TikTok Shop, they have a unique challenge in getting started on the platform, and actually operating in the black. One brand owner joked with me that, despite being only 30 years old, he had already aged out of the algorithm too quickly and just didn't know what was trending anymore. Good news is I'm 21, and I've been doing tiktok organic for ecom since...

Hey, Here's something we see all the time with big brands. They've got a long list of TikTok Shop creators. Many, many, many creators got samples and maybe even posted a few times, but then ultimately dropped off too quickly. And then the brand still ends up with way too little content that's actually going out. So then they try to find some new creators, and the cycle often, unfortunately, continues. Brands keep asking me: "How do we get our creators posting again?" First, you want to start...